Posted on: 01/22/17 12:12PM
Jerl said:
So this image is very much a grey area for me. I could honestly see it going either way - most of the depictions of her in that image I would say does not qualify for the tag, but the top left panel I can kinda see going that way with. The tag could conceivably apply because of a single panel in a comic strip. The "loli-ness" of that panel could also be conceivably overridden by the other depictions of the same character at the same time that don't fit our definition of a loli. I'm personally inclined to go with the latter, but regardless of personal opinion, Domestic_Importer is not incorrect in removing "loli", and removing the tag is most definitely not tag poisoning.
As for which tag should stay, at this point that's something you should bring up for discussion and vote in the Gardener's Guild.
Thanks for your response, I appreciate your impartiality and candor.
[Edit] It was above all precisely the panel that you mention that made me view the character as being just as arguably a "loli" as not.