Notice: My personal stance on AI generated artwork. Retweet and share if you agree. Let us discuss, and not immediately scream bloody murder.

Now Viewing: Subjective Tagging Discussion
Keep it civil, do not flame or bait other users. If you notice anything illegal or inappropriate being discussed, contact an administrator or moderator.

Len - Group: Member - Total Posts: 343
user_avatar
Posted on: 04/07/11 10:01PM

Doubt it, if you want it, you can just search cunnilingus and gokkun as that's what it is.

Regarding the Epic tag, I think we should take Danbooru's lead on it and reserve it for impossible or awe-inspiring actions, such as a massive fleet of ships, a single man taking on a behemoth and winning, or a battle between two extremely powerful beings like Superman vs Goku. I've seen a lot that can be better tagged as your_gonna_get_raped or badass. I think it should be given an explicit definition.



internetlovemachine - Group: Fleet Admiral Cat - Total Posts: 3836
user_avatar
Posted on: 04/07/11 10:45PM

Len said:
Regarding the Epic tag, I think we should take Danbooru's lead on it and reserve it for impossible or awe-inspiring actions, such as a massive fleet of ships, a single man taking on a behemoth and winning, or a battle between two extremely powerful beings like Superman vs Goku. I've seen a lot that can be better tagged as your_gonna_get_raped or badass. I think it should be given an explicit definition.


I agree with you on the epic tag, but:

1) "you_gonna_get_raped" needs some serious cleaning out as it is.
2) "badass" would be better consolidated into a pool like Danbooru does, if you ask me. But a paging system for pools pretty much needs to be implemented before I want to think about doing that.



BlueBaroness - Group: Dewrito Pope - Total Posts: 1278
user_avatar
Posted on: 04/14/11 02:51PM

'kakokou' has been changed to 'tottoto_tomekichi' over at Danbooru, but we still have three pages of the former over here.



Dolljoints - Group: Member - Total Posts: 113
user_avatar
Posted on: 04/14/11 09:40PM

There is a use for a 'female' tag.
'male' does not imply that there are only males in the picture. The current wiki definition is any picture containing a male character. People looking for pictures with only females are accomodated because they can add -male, and tag any remaining pictures that contain male characters with male to remove them from the results.

If you don't allow at least one of a 'female' tag or a male_only tag, then it's discrimination against users who are looking for pictures with only males. There is a wiki entry on male_only claiming that it's redundant, and to use male + solo or yaoi instead. That is not true, because not all pictures with only male characters are solo or yaoi, any more than all pictures with only girls are either solo or yuri.

Using male_only would at present require fewer pictures to be tagged. Using female has the advantage that it's equal treatment, and doesn't presuppose that the site's contents will always be slanted towards pictures of girls.



jedi1357 - Group: Moderator - Total Posts: 5747
user_avatar
Posted on: 04/15/11 10:35PM

"awesome" tag...really? Why did that escape my radar?

Oh, and the "win" tag too.



Xalrun - Group: Moderator - Total Posts: 4690
user_avatar
Posted on: 04/16/11 07:11PM

bad_art should be aliased with poorly_drawn.
edit:fixed



Anti_Gendou - Group: Moderator - Total Posts: 4357
user_avatar
Posted on: 04/18/11 12:29AM

I just now found Danbooru's "Commentary_Request" tag.

Should we get rid of it? Or should we port the Artist commentaries from there to here when the tag is used?



th8827 - Group: Retired Staff - Total Posts: 1264
user_avatar
Posted on: 04/18/11 12:40AM

Hmm... If you feel that the commentary is necessary, you can copy it over. However, I don't think that we'll require it, so you can remove the tags as you see fit.



internetlovemachine - Group: Fleet Admiral Cat - Total Posts: 3836
user_avatar
Posted on: 04/18/11 01:22PM

gelbooru.com/index.php?page=wiki&s=view&id=3441

Strikes me as entirely redundant with "bulge".



Len - Group: Member - Total Posts: 343
user_avatar
Posted on: 04/18/11 08:08PM

There's already stomach bulge for insertions that cause distension, so yes, completely redundant.



add_replyAdd Reply


«34567 8 910111213»