Now Viewing: [Tagging] Gardeners Guild: Discuss Tagging Here!
Keep it civil, do not flame or bait other users. If you notice anything illegal or inappropriate being discussed, contact an administrator or moderator.
Anybody serious willing to help tagging posts correctly?
Not only does that wiki page not say that or anything even resembling it, but there are multiple pages of newhalf characters who have the 1boy tag.
It's possible to be a male character who has breasts and that character would be tagged as a newhalf ("That is to say, the character has a female body but male genitals."), which is the umbrella Mariandale falls under.
smackmybitchup said: Mariandale is a transwoman, and so should be tagged as female.
This isn't a thing that's done here, so this means nothing.
BlueBaroness said: Not only does that wiki page not say that or anything even resembling it, but there are multiple pages of newhalf characters who have the 1boy tag.
From the wiki: Similar to futanari, but possessing no female genitalia. That is to say, the character has a female body but male genitals. And the multiples newhalf posts with 1boy are just mistagged. They need to be tagged correctly.
BlueBaroness said: It's possible to be a male character who has breasts and that character would be tagged as a newhalf ("That is to say, the character has a female body but male genitals."), which is the umbrella Mariandale falls under.
Newhalves are considered female. Furthermore, when there's a sex scene with a guy and a newhalf, the tag futa_with_male applies.
I used to be PM'd by mods about this, so I don't know why you would deny it.
We have a history of tagging trans characters by the gender they actually are rather than what they identify as in the copyright. Mariandale is still a male, so I agree with keeping the tags as they are.
smackmybitchup said: Anybody serious willing to help tagging posts correctly?
Haven't you been warned before about not talking down to moderators in such a way