Gelbooru

Notice: We are now selling NEW Gelbooru Merch~! Domestic shipping is free on all orders! Do you have an artist tag on Gelbooru? Let us know so we can properly credit you!

Ticket Information - ID: #488


ID:Category:SeverityReproducibilityDate SubmittedUpdated By:
0000488Feature RequestnormalN/A01/21/11 02:44PMRyan_tiger_rawr
ReporterNameless_Fairy
Assigned to:geltas
Resolution:Open
View StatusPublic
Version:
Target Version:N/A
Summary:Tag relations
Description:First, let me illustrate my feature request with an example. Suppose I want to find all images of Youmu with big breasts (blasphemy, I know, but please bear with me for a while). I type in "large_breasts konpaku_youmu" and what do I get? A lot of hits for flat Youmu with busty Yuyuko or some other character. Granted, there are only 4 pages of results total, but still. What's the general problem here? Large breasts are not a separate entity (well... unless it's ao_usagi). They are a property of a particular character in the image. Same for eye color, hair color, hair length, etc. This distinction is lost with a flat tag hierarchy.
My proposal is to alter the tagging system a bit. Entity tags would describe parts of the image itself: characters, objects, setting, whereas property tags would describe properties of some of the image entities and/or relationships between them. Alternatively, you could view entity tags as properties of the root object, the image itself. At the db level this is possible to implement in the image-tag crosslink table with an additional column for tag ids as parameters of a property "function".
Additional Info:
internetlovemachine replied at 2011-01-21 17:47:15
Instead of all that, why not just search for "large_breasts konpaku_youmu -saigyouji_yuyuko"?

Nameless_Fairy replied at 2011-01-25 18:43:22
Because that's not what I intended to search for. First, it is impractical to blacklist all characters which potentially have the desired property. Second, I might want not to exclude other characters.
Even if I wanted to find all Youmus with red or pink eyes I could patiently click through 35 pages and probably wouldn't die of exhaustion. This is not a problem with any particular search that cannot be solved through application of appropriate amounts of drudgery, it only served as an example. This is a proposal to make all future searches easier and more precise.